Masters of the Universe Origins “The American Nightmare” Cody Rhodes
WWEternia has more than one royal family. Protected by the legendary Nightmare Armor, "The American Nightmare" Cody Rhodes seeks to avenge his father's legacy. Roll drum until no dents appear. Strike armor... a dent shows. Strike again... two dents show.-
Wave: 9
Year: 2026
Retail: $19.99 UPC: 194735411863
ASIN: B0H6T4T6C6 (paid link) Series: Origins Group: Masters of the WWE Universe Action Figures
- View in: Price Guide | Visual Guide | Checklist
-
- Share:
- Help us improve this page
Where to Buy:
| Retailer | Price | Diff | Lowest Found |
|---|---|---|---|
 Sold Auctions | Avg: $30.60 | +$10.61 (+53%) | $16.50 |
| Buy It Now | Avg: $37.98 | +$17.99 (+90%) | $34.99 |
| Amazon | $62.21 | +$42.22 (+211%) | |
| AF411 Marketplace | 0 items for Sale. | ||
| When you click on links on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network and Amazon Associates program: Affiliate Disclosure | |||
The average price based upon the last 15 sold auctions is: $30.60
[High: $40.89/Low: $16.50]. The average Buy It Now price is $37.98 based upon 3 filtered active auctions out of 8.
[Not enough auctions to build price history graph]
Active auctions are not calculated into the price history graph. Rows that are gray are excluded from BIN calculations 
| Picture | Name | Current Price | Shipping | Type | Days Left |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Mattel Masters of the WWE Universe Cody Rhodes Action Figure w Sword Shield via * | $45.00 | Calculated | Buy it now | |
 | Mattel Masters of the WWE Universe Cody Rhodes American Nightmare Figure NEW via * | $38.96 | $5.99 | Buy it now | |
 | Masters of the WWE Universe Cody Rhodes The American Nightmare unpunched new via * | $34.99 | $8.15 | Buy it now | |
 | Mattel Masters of the WWE Universe Cody Rhodes Action Figure Sword Axe Sheet via * | $40.00 | Calculated | Buy it now | |
 | Masters of the WWE UNIVERSE CODY RHODES Unpunched Action Figure 2026 Mattel via * | $49.99 | Calculated | Buy it now | |
 | Masters of the WWE Universe Wave 9 Cody Rhodes Shawn Michaels NEW via * | $100.00 | Calculated | Buy it now | 1 |
 | Masters of the WWE Universe Wave 9 Cody Rhodes Shawn Michaels NEW via * | $90.00 | Calculated | Buy it now | |
 | Masters of the WWE Cody Rhodes IN HAND New Unpunched MOTU Action Figure 2026 via * | $49.99 | Calculated | Buy it now |
Items sold that determine avg selling price in Price History Graph
Rotate screen for more info.
This “The American Nightmare” Cody Rhodes toy was added on September 2026 and also released in 2026 with a retail price of $19.99. This action figure is part of the Masters of the Universe genre within the Origins series and included in Wave 9. It can be found online by using the following codes: UPC: 194735411863, Amazon ASIN: B0H6T4T6C6 (paid link) and on eBay (paid link). With an average selling price of $30.60, this toy is not very valuable as it's selling for about its original retail price. Quite a few (22) of these toys are in user collections so it does seem to be somewhat popular. Some of these figures are specifying that they are unpunched, which may have higher value over punched cardbacks.
Tip: All prices are calculated based upon new figures in the box.