| Blue Lantern (Gold Label - Kyle Rayner) | $19.99 | 377% | $95.28 | +$75.29 | 7 | Gold Label |
| Red Hood (DC New 52) | $19.99 | 375% | $94.99 | +$75.00 | 3 | McFarlane |
| Poison Ivy (Batman & Robin) | $24.99 | 343% | $110.83 | +$85.84 | 15 | Mr. Freeze (BAF) |
| Mister Freeze (Victor Fries - Platinum) | $19.99 | 309% | $81.66 | +$61.67 | 3 | McFarlane |
| Azrael Batman Armor (Gold Label - Knightfall) | $19.87 | 308% | $81.06 | +$61.19 | 10 | Gold Label |
| Donna Troy (Titans) | $24.99 | 275% | $93.67 | +$68.68 | 4 | Beast Boy (BAF) |
| The Flash (Gold Label - Flashpoint) | $24.99 | 269% | $92.30 | +$67.31 | 7 | Cyborg (BAF) |
| Robin Dick Grayson (Gold Label - Rebirth) | $22.99 | 254% | $81.43 | +$58.44 | 9 | Gold Label |
| Bane with Trench Coat (Gold Label - The Dark Knight Trilogy) | $30.00 | 240% | $102.03 | +$72.03 | 12 | Gold Label |
| Wonder Woman (Who is Wonder Woman) | $29.99 | 225% | $97.57 | +$67.58 | 7 | McFarlane Collector Edition |
| Catwoman (Batman: Knightfall) | $19.99 | 195% | $59.02 | +$39.03 | 16 | McFarlane |
| The Grim Knight (Batman Who Laughs) | $19.99 | 192% | $58.39 | +$38.40 | 15 | McFarlane |
| Batman (Arkham Knight) | $19.99 | 185% | $56.98 | +$36.99 | 9 | McFarlane |
| Superman (Justice League - Blue/Red suit) | $19.99 | 181% | $56.19 | +$36.20 | 15 | McFarlane |
| Kon-El Superboy (Comics) | $19.99 | 180% | $55.91 | +$35.92 | 13 | McFarlane |
| Batman Knightmare & Armor Suit (Gold Label - Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice) | $39.99 | 180% | $111.80 | +$71.81 | 5 | McFarlane Collector Edition |
| Catwoman | $24.99 | 174% | $68.41 | +$43.42 | 7 | Solomon Grundy (BAF) |
| Batman (Gold Label - Knightfall 30th Anniversary) | $30.00 | 171% | $81.25 | +$51.25 | 8 | Gold Label |
| The Comedian (Three Jokers) | $19.99 | 164% | $52.87 | +$32.88 | 11 | McFarlane |
| Alfred Pennyworth (Rebirth) | $19.99 | 158% | $51.50 | +$31.51 | 4 | Killer Croc 80th (CNC) |